38.6c New Delhi, India, Sunday, May 19, 2024
Judiciary

“Travesty of justice”: Karnataka HC takes exception to “zero conviction rate” in manual scavenging cases

By Rintu Mariam Biju      09 January, 2024 11:34 AM      0 Comments
Travesty of justice Karnataka HC takes exception to zero conviction rate in manual scavenging cases

BENGALURU: The Karnataka High Court took serious exception to the ‘zero conviction rate’ for the offence of manual scavenging in the State.  The Court noted that those who were involved in going against the State government’s ban against manual scavenging, weren’t bearing the penal consequences. 


“How is it 'zero conviction?'... Why no conviction? What is the remedy? Where is that action?... What a travesty of justice. We are not on compensation. Why not even a single conviction? What is your framework? How are you (state government) going to do this? The makers of our Constitution will shiver in their graves with the things we are doing”, a Bench of Chief Justice PB Varale and Justice Krishna Dixit asked, during the hearing yesterday. 


The Court also pointed out that it was perhaps, the lack of seriousness of lawyers and prosecutors that actually aided those people who still facilitate manual scavenging. “Where’s the action?” particularly against concerned substandard public prosecutors- this was the big question that Bench posed before the State government. 


The Bench was hearing a PIL plea which was initiated on the direction of the court after it came across certain news reports regarding the continued practise of manual scavenging in Karnataka. The reports pointed to deaths in manholes, social ostracism, and lack of compensation, among other persisting issues. 


The Bench also didn’t seem quite pleased with how the court had to set everything in motion to set things right, in terms of public issues. The Court opined that the State must come forward with appropriate measures. 


"Unless some secretary is imprisoned, nothing will improve in our State”, the Bench added. 


As the hearing gained momentum, the Court also took note of the fact that the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, is usually not invoked in cases registered against those employing manual scavengers, in spite of a provision to that effect. 


Amicus curiae Sridhar Prabhu stated that the provisions of the SC/ST Act must be invoked to ensure accountability. Only awarding compensation won’t be sufficient curb this social evil, he said. 


Affirming this argument, the Bench noted that section 3 (j) of the SC/ST Act was not invoked even in the recent criminal case lodged over the deaths of certain persons in a manual scavenging incident, last month. 


On the introduction of technology to replace manual scavenging, Advocate General Shashi Kiran Shetty assured the Court that the State government is in the process of securing technology and necessary machinery in a phased manner. 


The Court then asked both the State and Central government to file detailed affidavits in the matter. The case will next come up on January 30.



Share this article:

About:

Rintu Mariam Biju graduated from the National University of Advanced Legal Studies, Kochi after comp...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Karnataka High Court: Cabinet Rank Status Not Equivalent to Ministerial Position [Read Order] Karnataka High Court: Cabinet Rank Status Not Equivalent to Ministerial Position [Read Order]

Karnataka High Court clarifies that Cabinet rank status does not equate to ministerial position, dismissing a PIL challenging political appointments to Chief Minister Siddaramaiah.

Karnataka High Court Grants Protection to Journalist Sudhir Chaudhary Amid Fake News Controversy Karnataka High Court Grants Protection to Journalist Sudhir Chaudhary Amid Fake News Controversy

Karnataka High Court protects journalist Sudhir Chaudhary and Aaj Tak from coercive action over alleged 'fake news' about Karnataka government's minority scheme. Get the latest updates on this legal battle.

Ganeshotsav at Idgah Maidan: High Court Rejects Anjuman-E-Islam's Plea Against Ganesh Idol Installation Ganeshotsav at Idgah Maidan: High Court Rejects Anjuman-E-Islam's Plea Against Ganesh Idol Installation

Karnataka High Court rejects Anjuman-E-Islam's plea against Ganesh idol installation at Idgah Maidan in Hubballi. Get the latest updates on the legal battle and permissions for Ganesha festivities.

Woman living in adultery cannot claim maintenance: Karnataka High Court [Read Order] Woman living in adultery cannot claim maintenance: Karnataka High Court [Read Order]

Karnataka High Court rules that a woman engaged in adultery cannot claim maintenance, stating her dishonesty as a key factor.

TRENDING NEWS

sc-notice-to-ec-on-plea-by-adr-for-release-of-voters-turnout-data
Trending Judiciary
SC notice to EC on plea by ADR for release of voters turnout data

SC issues notice to EC on ADR plea to release voter turnout data. SC demands EC to disclose vote counts within 48 hours after each phase of the 2024 Lok Sabha polls.

18 May, 2024 11:16 AM
delhi-hc-refuses-jackie-shroff-interim-relief-against-youtuber-unfilteredthugesh-for-alleged-personality-rights-infringement
Trending CelebStreet
Delhi HC refuses Jackie Shroff interim relief against Youtuber 'UnfilteredThugesh' for using "Thug Life" in video on Shroff

The Delhi High Court has refused Jackie Shroff interim relief against Youtuber 'UnfilteredThugesh' for alleged personality rights' infringement.

18 May, 2024 05:20 PM

TOP STORIES

indian-courts-this-week-law-street-journals-weekly-round-up-of-sc-hcs-may-6-may-10
Trending Judiciary
Indian Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [May 6 - May 10]

Get the latest updates from India's Supreme Court and the High Courts ! Here’s a round up of the week's top legal stories in a quick, easy-to-read summary.

13 May, 2024 10:29 AM
sc-dismisses-union-govt-plea-against-bail-to-maoist-financer-in-case-of-attack-on-police-party-in-jharkhand
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses Union govt's plea against bail to Maoist financer in case of attack on police party in Jharkhand [Read Judgment]

SC rejects govt's plea against bail for accused in Jharkhand police attack case, citing absence of violated bail conditions.

13 May, 2024 11:33 AM
supreme-court-upholds-gang-rape-conviction-though-victim-turned-hostile
Trending Judiciary
Supreme Court upholds gang rape conviction, though victim turned hostile [Read Judgment]

SC upholds gang rape conviction despite victim's hostility, affirming witness credibility in criminal trials.

13 May, 2024 12:24 PM
sanatana-dharma-remarks-sc-seeks-response-from-up-maha-ktka-bihar-jamp;k-on-udhayanidhis-plea-for-clubbing-firs
Trending Judiciary
Sanatana Dharma remarks SC seeks response from UP, Maha, Ktka, Bihar, J&K on Udhayanidhi's plea for clubbing FIRs

SC seeks response on Udhayanidhi's plea for clubbing FIRs related to his remarks on 'Sanatan Dharma'.

13 May, 2024 12:39 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email