38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, May 24, 2024

Supreme Court Refuses to Stay Patna High Court Order Halting Caste Survey in Bihar

By LawStreet News Network      20 May, 2023 01:51 AM      0 Comments
Supreme Court Refuses to Stay Patna HC Order Halting Caste Survey in Bihar

NEW DELHI: In yet another setback to the Nitish Kumar government, the Supreme Court on Thursday refused to stay the Patna High Court's interim order which had halted a caste survey with immediate effect.

On May 4, the HC prima facie held that the state government does not have power to undertake such an exercise under the garb of survey.

Dealing with Bihar government's appeal, a bench of Justices Abhay S Oka and Rajesh Bindal asked why it should interfere at this stage and told the state government to convass its arguments before the High Court, which had fixed the matter for hearing on July 3.

As senior advocate Shyam Divan for the Bihar government pressed for some order, the court said it would have to be determined if the exercise being carried out is a census in garb of survey as held by the High Court.

"We are making it clear, this is not a case where we can grant you interim relief," the bench told the counsel.

The court agreed to consider the plea on July 14, if the HC could not hear the matter on the fixed date.

Divan, however, submitted that it required only 10 days to complete the process of survey, which began in January this year.

He also contended that the survey was voluntary and not on a 100% basis like a census.

He said that there was no question of sharing any data as feared by the High Court.

The counsel claimed the State has got legislative competence to collect statistics.

In its appeal, the state government said the collection of caste-based data is a constitutional mandate under Articles 15 and 16 of the Constitution.

The first round of caste survey in Bihar was conducted between January 7 and 21. The second round started on April 15 and was supposed to continue till May 15.

On a batch of writ petitions filed by 'Youth for Equality' and others, the HC had on May 4 directed the Bihar government to immediately stop the caste based survey, by prima facie holding that the State has no power to carry out such an exercise.

It also directed the government to ensure that data already collected are secured and not shared with anybody till final orders.

The court noted "the caste-based survey is a census in the garb of a survey; the power to carry out which is exclusively on the Union Parliament".

In its detailed 31-page order, the HC had expressed serious reservation on sharing of the data collected in the survey started in January this year on the basis of government order issued on June 6, 2022.

"We also see from the notification issued that the Government intends to share data with the leaders of different parties of the State Assembly, the ruling party and opposition party which is also a matter of great concern. There definitely arises the larger question of right to privacy, which the Supreme Court has held to be a facet of right to life," the HC's division bench had said.

Share this article:

User Avatar

Leave a feedback about this

Trending Judiciary
No legal mandate for uploading of Form 17C on website or handing over to anyone other than candidate or agent, EC tells SC

EC tells SC there's no legal mandate to upload Form 17C on websites or provide it to anyone other than candidates or agents, citing risks of misuse and mistrust.

23 May, 2024 11:28 AM
Trending Judiciary
'National security always paramount,' SC cancels bail of PFI members [Read Judgment]

SC emphasizes national security, cancels bail of eight PFI members, stressing balance between civil liberties and counter-terrorism under UAPA.

23 May, 2024 12:05 PM


Trending Judiciary
SC notice to EC on plea by ADR for release of voters turnout data

SC issues notice to EC on ADR plea to release voter turnout data. SC demands EC to disclose vote counts within 48 hours after each phase of the 2024 Lok Sabha polls.

18 May, 2024 11:16 AM
Trending Judiciary
Recovered direct chats between Kejriwal and hawala operators on transfer of money, ED claims before SC

ED claims to have recovered direct chats between Kejriwal and hawala operators on money transfer in Delhi liquor policy scam; SC reserves judgement on arrest appeal.

18 May, 2024 11:47 AM
Trending CelebStreet
Delhi HC refuses Jackie Shroff interim relief against Youtuber 'UnfilteredThugesh' for using "Thug Life" in video on Shroff

The Delhi High Court has refused Jackie Shroff interim relief against Youtuber 'UnfilteredThugesh' for alleged personality rights' infringement.

18 May, 2024 05:20 PM
Trending Judiciary
Abuse under SC/ST Act has to be in public view to make out offence: SC [Read Judgment]

SC rules abuse under SC/ST Act must be in public view. Case involves Olympic Riding and Equestrian Academy, highlighting key requirements for the offence.

18 May, 2024 05:45 PM


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email