38.6c New Delhi, India, Sunday, June 23, 2024
Judiciary

‘Not befitting judicial officer’: Gujarat HC upholds dismissal of judge who wrote ‘intemperate’ letter, abstained from work

By Rintu Mariam Biju      27 December, 2023 05:28 PM      0 Comments
Not befitting judicial officer Gujarat High Court upholds dismissal of judge who wrote intemperate letter abstained from work

While stating it is not befitting a judicial officer, the Gujarat High Court upheld the dismissal of a magistrate who took unauthorised leave after sending an "intemperate" letter to an administrative judge of the High Court and the principal district judge of Vadodara in 2013.
 

Viewing unauthorized absence of an ordinary employee, may perceive a different perception, a bench of Justices Biren Vaishnav and Nisha Thakore said. 
 

“Similar standards cannot and should not be applied in case of a Judicial Officer who abandons his service in defiance by addressing a letter to his Principal District Judge that unless a particular issue is not resolved he shall not report for duty. The report of the committee on the administrative side of this court, has therefore, rightly recorded that such a conduct on the part of the delinquent officer is not befitting the Judicial Officer”.
 

The plea was moved by Nileshbhai Chauhan, a magistrate who took unauthorised leave in 2013. From April 24, 2013 till May 10, 2013, during which the petitioner was on authorised leave, a news article regarding a sudden strike called by lawyers of Vadodara, caught his eye. He informed the principal district judge about it.
 

Subsequently, he wrote a letter using "intemperate" language stating that the whole judicial system was facing a "rot" by virtue of elements such as the protesting lawyers. Allegations against the principal district judge and the administrative judge of the High Court were also made in the letter. The letter also revealed that Chauhan would not report to work till the issue is resolved and took unauthorised leave from May 13 to July 11, 2013. 
 

The High Court, on the administrative side, recommended his dismissal. And so, in 2015, he was dismissed from service for several reasons - one, for making baseless allegations, two, for using undignified language against the High Court's administrative judge and the principal district judge at Vadodara, and three, for taking an unauthorised absence from duty. Aggrieved, the petitioner moved the High Court challenging his dismissal order. 
 

It was argued that the 2013 letter only indicated the petitioner’s anguish to the extent that the lawyers were proceeding on strike despite a Supreme Court judgement. The letter nowhere indicated any use of any intemperate or undignified language and therefore could not have been made an issue so as to warrant a charge-sheet. 
 

It was further contended that the petitioner, being an honest and upright officer, the dismissal order was shockingly disproportionate. 
Advocate Trusha Patel for the respondents submitted that the penalty of dismissal was just and proper. Even in the past, the petitioner has been in the habit of addressing letters using intemperate language and making baseless allegations. On the 2013 letter, she argued that it was highly unbecoming of a judicial officer to abandon his duties which would tantamount to going on strike.
 

Noting the rival arguments, the Court observed that a judicial officer could be justified in venting against the system. But in a dignified manner. 
“Obviously, a judicial officer may be justified in venting his anguish against the system but in doing so the language used in the letter would indicate that he roped in the administrative judge of the High Court and the District Judge in saying that elements were encouraging and cooperating in bringing such a systematic decline”, the Court noted while declining to accept the petitioner’s prayer.



Share this article:

About:

Rintu Mariam Biju graduated from the National University of Advanced Legal Studies, Kochi after comp...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Supreme Court Affirms Women's Right to Reproductive Choices as Central to Human Dignity [Read Order] Supreme Court Affirms Women's Right to Reproductive Choices as Central to Human Dignity [Read Order]

The Supreme Court of India emphasizes the right of women to make reproductive choices, stating it is integral to human dignity. The court's decision in a rape survivor's case highlights the importance of a woman's authority in deciding to terminate a pregnancy and underscores the impact of external conditions on human dignity.

Ahmedabad Court Dismisses Kejriwal and Sanjay Singh's Plea in Defamation Case Linked to PM Modi's Degrees Ahmedabad Court Dismisses Kejriwal and Sanjay Singh's Plea in Defamation Case Linked to PM Modi's Degrees

Ahmedabad court rejects Kejriwal and Sanjay Singh's plea against defamation case summons by Gujarat University. Get the latest update on the criminal defamation case involving PM Modi's academic degrees.

Gujarat High Court to Review Controversial Haryanvi Song 'Court Me Goli' Amid Judiciary Disrespect Allegations Gujarat High Court to Review Controversial Haryanvi Song 'Court Me Goli' Amid Judiciary Disrespect Allegations

Read about the Gujarat High Court's decision to scrutinize the Haryanvi song 'Court Me Goli' amid allegations of disrespect towards the judiciary. Learn more about the PIL concerns, the song's lyrics, and the specific line in question.

PM's Degree: HC issues notice to Gujarat University on plea by Kejriwal, Sanjay Singh PM's Degree: HC issues notice to Gujarat University on plea by Kejriwal, Sanjay Singh

Get the latest updates on the defamation case involving Arvind Kejriwal and Sanjay Singh from AAP against Gujarat University regarding Prime Minister Narendra Modi's degrees. Stay informed about the legal proceedings and controversies surrounding this case.

TRENDING NEWS

new-anti-cheating-law-enacted-analysis
Trending Executive
New Anti-Cheating Law enacted: Analysis

In-depth analysis of India’s new Anti-Cheating Law, the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024, aimed at curbing exam malpractices.

22 June, 2024 11:38 AM
calcutta-hc-closes-suit-between-dabur-india-and-youtuber-dhruv-rathee-for-trademark-infringement-of-real-fruit-juice
Trending Judiciary
Calcutta HC closes suit between Dabur India and YouTuber Dhruv Rathee for trademark infringement of Real fruit juice [Read Order]

A year after Calcutta High Court said that Youtuber Dhruv Rathee crossed the 'Lakshman Rekha', Rathee's proposal to withdraw 'Real' juice trademark from video gets accepted by Dabur.

22 June, 2024 02:47 PM

TOP STORIES

women-including-housewife-approach-ncw-against-controversial-ips-officer-gyaneshwar-singh
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Women, including housewife, approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh

Two women approach NCW against controversial IPS officer Gyaneshwar Singh, citing harassment for tweets based on news reports about his involvement in high-profile cases.

17 June, 2024 03:10 PM
courts-this-week-law-street-journal-s-weekly-round-up-of-sc-anf-hcs-june-10-june-15
Trending Judiciary
Courts this Week: Law Street Journal's Weekly Round-Up of SC & HCs [June 10 - June 15]

Get the latest updates from the Supreme Court of India and the High Courts ! Here’s a round up of the week's top legal stories in a quick, easy-to-read summary.

17 June, 2024 03:29 PM
man-sues-apple-for-5-million-blaming-company-for-divorce-after-wife-discovers-deleted-messages-with-sex-workers
Trending Business
Man sues Apple for £5 million, blaming company for divorce after wife discovers ‘deleted messages’ with sex workers

A UK man sues Apple for £5M, claiming their unclear policy on deleted messages led to his divorce after his wife found texts to sex workers on another device.

17 June, 2024 04:26 PM
ex-karnataka-cm-yediyurappa-appears-before-cid-for-pocso-case-probe-with-protection-of-no-arrest
Trending Crime, Police And Law
Ex-Karnataka CM Yediyurappa appears before CID for POCSO case probe, with protection of 'no arrest'

Ex-Karnataka CM Yediyurappa appears before CID for POCSO case probe, denies allegations, granted ‘no arrest’ protection. Next hearing: June 28.

17 June, 2024 04:46 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email