38.6c New Delhi, India, Wednesday, June 19, 2024
Judiciary

CBI not under control of Centre, SG tells Supreme Court

By Jhanak Singh      03 May, 2024 11:14 AM      0 Comments
CBI not under control of Centre, SG tells SC

NEW DELHI: The Centre on Thursday told the Supreme Court that CBI is not under the "control" of the Union government and it can't supervise either the registration of offence by the agency or its investigation.

The assertion before the top court comes at a time when several opposition leaders accused the central government of abusing the power to CBI to target them.

In preliminary objections to an original suit filed by the West Bengal government, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta raised questions before a bench of Justices B R Gavai and Sandeep Mehta over maintainability of the plea made by the state government.

The Mamata Banerjee government, had withdrawn consent to the CBI on November 16, 2018.

It claimed the central agency was going ahead with its investigation without securing the prerequisite nod from the state.

Appearing for the WB government, senior advocate Kapil Sibal for the WB government said once a foothold is given to the CBI in a state, the ED also entered, having huge ramification on the polity of the country.

Mehta, on behalf of the Centre, contended that Article 131 is "one of the most sacred" jurisdiction conferred upon the apex court and can't be allowed to be misused or abused.

He said the cases referred to in the state's suit have not been filed by the Union of India.

"The Union of India has not registered any case. CBI has done," Mehta said, adding that state has arrayed the Union of India represented by secretary of the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) as party in the suit.

"CBI is not under the control of Union of India," he said.

The solicitor general said that cases referred to in the suit include those which were ordered to be registered by the Calcutta High Court.

"The supervision (of CBI) is not with the Union of India. I (Centre) can't supervise either registration of the offence, I can't supervise the investigation and I can't supervise how it would lead to either a closure or a charge sheet or conviction or acquittal," Mehta said.

He also referred to the provisions of the Delhi Special Police Establishment (DSPE) Act, 1946 to buttress his contention.

He said the suit filed by the West Bengal was not maintainable because there was no cause of action against the Union of India.

Mehta said the similar issue and same question is already pending adjudication before the apex court in a special leave petition (SLP) and this fact has been suppressed by the state in the suit.

"This is a suit filed before the highest court of the country and my submission as a constitutional proposition is going to be that the suppression of fact must lead to dismissal of the suit only on that ground," he said.

Sibal, on his part, said the CBI is not a statutory authority and it is an investigating agency.

"Why can't it be considered to be a statutory authority," the bench asked.

On this, Sibal said, "It (CBI) is an investigating arm of the government."

He referred to the provisions of the DSPE Act, including Section 4 which deals with superintendence and administration of special police establishment.

"In the administrative structure of the Union of India, the supervision of the police establishment is with the Department of Personnel and Training," he said.

Sibal said when a question is asked in Parliament about the CBI, it is the minister of state for DoPT who answers it.

Referring to Section 6 of the DSPE Act, which deals with consent of state government to exercise of powers and jurisdiction, he said once the state has withdrawn its consent, the CBI can't enter the state and investigate.

"I am saying under the federal structure of this country, once a state has withdrawn consent, no investigating agency can enter into it. This does not apply, for example under the PMLA (Prevention of Money Laundering Act)," he said.

The court would hear further arguments on May 8.
 



Share this article:

About:

Jhanak is a lawyer by profession and legal journalist by passion. She graduated at the top of her cl...Read more

Follow:
FacebookTwitterLinkedinInstagram


Leave a feedback about this
Related Posts
View All

Ayodhya verdict: SC rules in favour of Ram Lalla, Sunni Waqf Board gets alternate land Ayodhya verdict: SC rules in favour of Ram Lalla, Sunni Waqf Board gets alternate land

SC bench led by CJI Ranjan Gogoi has allotted the dispute site to Ram Janmabhoomi Nyas, while directing the government to allot an alternate 5 acre land within Ayodhya to Sunni Waqf Board to build a mosque.

Supreme Court Top Panel Names Chief Justices for Bombay, Orissa and Meghalaya High Courts Supreme Court Top Panel Names Chief Justices for Bombay, Orissa and Meghalaya High Courts

The Orissa High Court has been without a permanent chief justice since January 5, 2020 after the retirement of former Chief Justice, KS Jhaveri. The high court is currently headed by acting Chief Justice Sanju Panda.

Himachal Pradesh High Court Grant Bail to a Man Accused of Committing Unnatural Acts with Cow, Said that there is no Criminal History Depicting Pervert Mind [READ ORDER] Himachal Pradesh High Court Grant Bail to a Man Accused of Committing Unnatural Acts with Cow, Said that there is no Criminal History Depicting Pervert Mind [READ ORDER]

without commenting on the merits of the case at this stage of investigation and the period of detention he faced in jail, the Court after analyzing all things allowed bail to the accused person ( Jai Ram). Himachal Pradesh High Court, Grant Bail, Justice Anup Chitrakara

How the Waqf Board has the third largest ownership of land after the Indian Railways and the Defense Dept.? How the Waqf Board has the third largest ownership of land after the Indian Railways and the Defense Dept.?

SHO Bhardwaj was quick to defend the Maulvi in questioning regarding the Mazar but harassed the reported who sought truth. Why did the SHO have to harass a Media reporter when he was doing his job? Who benefits from this? Why is there a Mazar on a flyover? Why is a Minority Welfare development Board in control of so much property? || #Mazar #SHOBhardwaj #Mazar #Mosque #WaqfBoard #Islam #News #Waqf #RemoveSHOBharadwaj

TRENDING NEWS

historic-moment-all-four-gates-of-puris-jagannath-temple-reopened-after-bjps-landmark-victory-in-odisha
Trending News Updates
Historic Moment: All Four Gates of Puri’s Jagannath Temple Reopened After BJP’s Landmark Victory in Odisha

Historic Moment All Four Gates of Puris Jagannath Temple Reopened After BJPs Landmark Victory in Odisha

18 June, 2024 11:03 AM
education-minister-admits-irregularities-in-neet-ug-centre-nta-to-face-probing-queries-in-sc
Trending Executive
Education Minister admits irregularities in NEET UG; Centre, NTA to face probing queries in SC

Education Minister admits irregularities in NEET UG; Centre, NTA to face SC probe over exam conduct and paper leak allegations, counselling to proceed.

18 June, 2024 12:14 PM

TOP STORIES

karan-johar-moves-bombay-high-court-against-film-shaadi-ke-director-karan-aur-johar
Trending CelebStreet
Karan Johar moves Bombay High Court against film ‘Shaadi Ke Director Karan Aur Johar’

Karan Johar files a lawsuit in Bombay High Court against the film “Shaadi Ke Director Karan Aur Johar,” seeking to prevent the use of his name in the title.

13 June, 2024 12:01 AM
conspired-to-transform-india-into-an-islamic-country-by-2047-bombay-hc-denies-bail-to-3-islamists-pfi-members
Trending Judiciary
Conspired to transform India into an Islamic country by 2047: Bombay HC denies bail to 3 Islamists PFI members [Read Order]

Bombay High Court denies bail to three PFI members accused of plotting to turn India into an Islamic state by 2047, citing strong evidence and risk of tampering.

13 June, 2024 12:37 AM
delhi-hc-refuses-to-stay-neet-ug-admissions-counselling-over-paper-leak-allegations
Trending Judiciary
Delhi HC refuses to stay NEET-UG admissions counselling, over paper leak allegations

Delhi High Court refuses to stay NEET-UG 2024 counselling amidst allegations of irregularities.

13 June, 2024 12:48 PM
centre-to-hold-re-test-for-1563-candidates-awarded-grace-marks-in-neet-ug-2024
Trending Judiciary
Centre to hold re-test for 1563 candidates awarded grace marks in NEET UG, 2024 [Read Order]

Centre to hold re-test for 1563 candidates awarded grace marks in NEET UG 2024. Date for re-test to be notified on June 13, results by June 30.

13 June, 2024 01:39 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email