38.6c New Delhi, India, Friday, March 29, 2024
Judiciary

50% quota ceiling only for SC/ST, OBC: SC [Read Order]

By LawStreet News Network      08 November, 2022 07:36 PM      0 Comments
50% quota ceiling only for SC/ST, OBC: SC Read Order

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Monday said that the 50 % ceiling for reservation, fixed by the nine-judge bench in 1992 in Mandal Commission case, is applicable only to the SC/ST and OBC categories as the 10 % EWS quota in jobs and education was over and above the limit.

Of the five-judge Constitution bench, Justice Dinesh Maheshwari, along with Justice Bela M Trivedi and J B Pardiwala upheld validity of the 103 rd Constitutional Amendment Act, 2019, holding that the provision does not breach the basic structure of the Constitution.

Chief Justice U U Lalit and Justice S Ravindra Bhat, however, held the amendments by creating a different kind of criteria, becomes a gateway for further infractions which in fact would result in compartmentalization.

In this regard, the observations of B R Ambedkar have to be kept in mind that the reservations are to be seen temporary and exceptional or else they would “eat up the rule of equality", he wrote on behalf of himself and the CJI.

Justice Bhat also sounded cautionary note as 69% reservation in Tamil Nadu was pending adjudication and the majority view may seal its fate without hearing the parties concerned.

"The view of the members of this bench constituting the majority - that creation of another class which can be a recipient of up to 10% of the reservation, over 
and above 50%, which is permitted under Articles 15(4) or 16(4), in my 
considered opinion, therefore, has a direct bearing on the likely outcome in the challenge in that (TN law) proceeding. I would therefore sound this cautionary note since this judgment may well seal the fate of the pending litigation -
without the benefit of hearing in those proceedings," Justice Bhat said.

He kept 50% rule for reservation open for future consideration.

In his judgement, Justice Maheshwari said the ceiling limit itself is not inflexible and in any case, and it applies only to the reservations envisaged by Articles 15(4), 15(5) and 16(4) of the Constitution.

This ceiling limit, though held attached to the constitutional requirements, has not been held to be inflexible and inviolable for all times to come, he said.

“Prescription of ceiling limit of 50%, being apparently for the benefit of general merit candidates, does not provide any justified cause to the candidates standing in the bracket of already available reservation to raise any grievance about extra 10% reservation for the benefit of another section of society in need of affirmative action," he said.

“In any case, there is no question of violation of any such basic feature of the Constitution that the entire structure of equality of opportunity in Article 16 would collapse by this EWS reservation”, he added.

Justice Maheshwari further wrote the 50% ceiling proposition would obviously be applied only to those reservations which were in place before the amendment in question.

"No decision of this court could be read to mean that even if the Parliament finds the necessity of another affirmative action by the State in the form of reservation for a section or class in need, it could never be provided," he said.

Read Order



Share this article:

User Avatar
About:


Leave a feedback about this
TRENDING NEWS

arvind-kejriwals-plea-for-interim-release-rejected-by-delhi-high-court
Trending Judiciary
Arvind Kejriwal's plea for interim release rejected by Delhi High Court [Read Order]

Delhi High Court rejects Arvind Kejriwal's plea for interim release in money laundering case related to liquor policy scam, pending ED's response.

28 March, 2024 10:50 AM
youtuber-strings-plea-against-youtube-accounts-suspension-andhra-pradesh-hc-issues-notice-to-centre-google
Trending Top Stories
BREAKING: Youtuber String’s plea against Youtube accounts suspension: Andhra Pradesh HC issues notice to Centre, Google

Andhra Pradesh High Court issues notice to the Centre and Google LLC on Youtube journalist String’s plea against suspension of its accounts by Google (which owns Youtube).

28 March, 2024 11:26 AM

TOP STORIES

delhi-liquor-scam-court-remands-arvind-kejriwal-to-ed-custody-till-march-28-read-remand-application
Trending Judiciary
Delhi liquor scam: Court remands Arvind Kejriwal to ED custody till March 28 [Read Order]

Delhi liquor scam: Arvind Kejriwal remanded to ED custody till March 28. Court grants agency permission for interrogation in liquor policy case.

23 March, 2024 11:53 AM
sc-dismisses-centres-plea-for-review-of-judgment-directing-ed-to-furnish-written-grounds-of-arrest-to-pmla-accused
Trending Judiciary
SC dismisses Centre’s plea for review of judgment directing ED to furnish written grounds of arrest to PMLA accused [Read Order]

Supreme Court dismisses Centre's plea, upholds judgment mandating Enforcement Directorate to provide written grounds of arrest in PMLA cases.

23 March, 2024 03:14 PM
kerala-hc-to-hear-lesbian-couples-plea-against-forced-conversion-therapy-on-april-9
Trending Judiciary
Kerala HC to hear lesbian couple’s plea against forced conversion therapy on April 9

Kerala HC will hear a lesbian couple’s plea highlighting that one of them was subjected to forced conversion therapy.

23 March, 2024 03:30 PM
how-can-people-be-compelled-to-vote-madras-hc-asks
Trending Judiciary
“How can people be compelled to vote? Madras HC asks

“How can people be compelled to vote?”, the Madras HC queried in a plea asking employers in Tamil Nadu to demand proof from employees of having voted on polling day.

23 March, 2024 05:04 PM

ADVERTISEMENT


Join Group

Signup for Our Newsletter

Get Exclusive access to members only content by email